Original Best Foods Chocolate Mayonnaise Cake Recipe | CDKitchen.com (2024)

reviews & comments

1. kucook REVIEW:
   April 11, 2021

   This is one of our favorite cakes. It turns out perfect every time. Super moist and the right amoutn of chocolate flavor.

2. Sacha REVIEW:
   October 3, 2020

   this recipe is a waste of time. The instructions were followed exactly and the cake although looked really good, tasted awful. You could taste the mayonnaise in it and it was far from light. More like a stodgy mayonnaise brownie. I am a home baker and have baked many cakes before all oh which highly impressive and I was disappointed in this.

   • CDKitchen Staff Reply:

     Sorry you weren't happy with the cake. This recipe has been around a long time and is quite popular. I'd try a different brand of mayonnaise (the original recipe is from Hellman's so maybe try that brand?). Definitely avoid generic or store brands.

     See Also

     50 Christmas Eve Party Recipes

3. Carolyn Ellertson REVIEW:
   March 8, 2020

   I have made this cake for half a century or more. Growing up it was my son's favorite chocolate cake.. so much so he asked for the largest tier of his wedding cake to be of it. (I made the cake..)..and people loved every bite! Today I am making it because it popped into my head, and we were hungry for chocolate cake.. a rich, moist, wonderful piece..which by the way, this cake will mold before it gets dried out! And remember..the mayo replaces the oil and eggs..so keep it handy in case you don't have any. That little boy's son will be married in July..our first grandchild to marry, and it made me think of his own wedding and that cake. Umm. I have to get back to the kitchen.. I couldn't find my recipe, so headed for the computer. Thank you for having it!!

4. Ianaday REVIEW:
   November 24, 2019

   I am 71 and I remember my Mom and my grandmother making the original mayonnaise cake. The recipe was on the back of the label on the quart of mayonnaise. It was and I’d the best chocolate cake ever

5. Lorna REVIEW:
   March 1, 2019

   Made this cake for my granddaughter's birthday. It was delicious. I will make it again.

6. Ray REVIEW:
   October 3, 2017

   Excellent version of the Hellman's Original Chocolate Cake. I had copied it and left out the amount of sugar (!) so have been improvising for years. I never measure vanilla...just a healthy dash and this cake is best made with Hershey's Original Cocao, not the Extra Dark. I added a sprinkle of cinnamon to dry ingredients and used the traditional hot coffee. Whether coffee or water, try to use HOT because it effects the baking soda to leaven the cake. Just hoping I have enough 10x to make frosting, also baked in a bundt pan, buttered/floured.

7. Karen REVIEW:
   April 20, 2017

   This cake was so easy to make that I didn't really think it would taste like anything special. WRONG. My guests literally moaned in delight. I've never received so many positive comments on a cake before. I'm still astounded that something so easy to prepare could be so incredibly moist, chocolaty, and delicious. I used cake flour and a very high quality cocoa. I love Hellmans/Best Foods mayonnaise and here's another reason to make sure there is always an extra jar in the pantry. My family has promoted me to "Star Baker!"

8. Guest Foodie June 15, 2016

   The original Mayonnaise cake from my mom in the 50's is2 cups sifted cake flour1 cup sugar1 tsp baking power1 tsp baking soda1/4 tsp salt1/2 cup cocoaCombine & sift tog. then add 1 cup mayonnaise,1 cup cold water1 tsp vanilla, blend well pour into cake pan.Bake 350 30 to 35 mins. Moms was the best I have ever eaten.She made her own frosting but can't find her recipe (so sad)

9. Guest Foodie March 4, 2016

   The original Does NOT have eggs. Look for Vintage picture online with birthday candles on the cake. However the actual original is one layer 9 inch cake. There are many online but they do not all agree on measurements. The real original was printed in 1937.

10. Guest Foodie REVIEW:
    February 25, 2016

    I have the 1979 "That Amazing Ingredient: Mayonnaise!'Recipes in the tradition of Hellman's and Best Foods Mayonnaise'" and the posted recipe is exactly as written. It is a killer cake. Enjoy!

11. djbaker REVIEW:
    July 3, 2013

    This is the first mayonnaise cake I've tried but I'm sold! I can't believe how good it was! I'm going to make another one soon.

12. Alimuffmtl REVIEW:
    April 24, 2011

    I have made this recipe many times - always a winner. Very moist and tasty!

13. Guest Foodie REVIEW:
    March 21, 2011

    We have made this in my family for many years. We also use regular Miracle Whip and 1 tsp vanilla.This cake is so easy to make and very tasty.

14. Rich K REVIEW:
    September 30, 2009

    I did not make the cake as indicated in this recipe, but the $100 cake has been a favorite in our family and extended family for over 50 years.The differences are as follows:-We use regular Miracle Whip instead of light-Use cold coffee (brewed or instant) instead of water-Increase vanilla to 1 teaspoon

15. Robertshowse REVIEW:
    February 18, 2008

    We have a recipe from an older magazine that is the same with the exception that it calls for 4 eggs. This cake turns out noticeably richer than the 3 egg version.

16. TinaMarie REVIEW:
    July 18, 2007

    BEST Choc Cake EVER!!!TRY IT, do yourself a Favor!

17. holconrad REVIEW:
    January 28, 2007

    This recipe is not only easy to prepare it is absolutely delicious!!

18. baychel3 May 25, 2006

    This recipe is NOT the original 'Mayonnaise' cake -- the original cake did not use eggs at all -- that's what was so special about it -- I remember (in the 50s) when this cake came out and was the "RAGE"!